Showing posts with label notchable burr. Show all posts
Showing posts with label notchable burr. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Fedex-day

My team within Autodesk experimented with a concept that is called Fedex-day, which translated as a one day project that absolutely without exception had to happen in 24 hours and be completed. The team all did this on the same day. We unplugged from our normal daily routine, were not allowed to schedule any meetings or calls, turned off our email and hid our phones. Our task was to come up with a one day project, that at we could execute within 24 hours, then document it and report out to our team the next morning. It could be any topic, but it had to result in something. You could not use it as an excuse to sleep all day.

We had team members who did videos, one that wrote a short story, one that created a database of worldwide relationships, and others that created new ways of engagement for the team. My project became the kickoff of my dream. I had been wondering about how to execute the burr puzzle cabin, and always realized the most critical step was the execution of the corner. The corner is a six-piece burr that is replicated 8 times to form the main frame of the cabin. It is the first key and arguably the most complex of the joints. If I could create this joint, then I could create the cabin. So my Project for FEDEX day was born.

I had already determined at the most practical working size for the frame were 6x6s mainly because of the weight of a 16 foot long timber which was the most practical and readily available size to use for the first cabin. An 8x8 of the same length was simply to heavy to handle, and probably overkill. So I picked up a few 6x6 wood posts which is the only material needed and pondered the process.

There are two fundamental cuts in any notchable burr. One is a notch the width of the "post" by half its width and the other is half its width by half its width. That is to say in this case 5.5 by 2.75 inches and 2.75 by 2.75 inches since a nominal 6x6 is actually 5.5 inches. With this combination all the notch combinations can be made.

On a small puzzle this can be done with repeated cuts on a table saw, a dado blade or a router. On a larger scale, the typical method for timber appeared to be to cut relief cuts the width of the final notch and then chisel the remainder of the notch to clean it. Therefore I needed a saw that could cut 2.75 inches deep. I could not bring myself to use a hand saw unless it was the last resort. I needed a 10 inch circular saw. A task easy to find at the contractor rental stores. Well easier said than done. I called everyone, and no where in my area was anything like this available to rent. So I looked for local stores to buy one, and that was a lost cause also. No one could get me one in time for Fedex-day. The hand saw was looking better at this point.

But alas, after moaning about how strangely hard it was to find a saw, my brother discovered a friend of his that had a 12 inch circular saw. My backbreaking work with a handsaw was avoided, but then the beast showed up. It was huge. The biggest saw I have ever seen. (Even though now have a 16 inch saw, but that is a different blog post.) The saw was the key, and Fedex-day day arrived, with me ready to go.

I think there is no need to write about the process since I can show you it all in pictures. I placed them in order below and you can follow the details picture by picture.
















My Conversation Starter On My Front Porch
The result was a big puzzle, but the key to a bigger process. It stood on my front porch for a while, then my back deck and now that I have a model shop, it is the first thing you see as you ascend the stairs. I knew that this trial run would teach me some valuable lessons, so here they are:
  • The accuracy of the depth of the cuts was critical, and this large saw was not designed to have good control over the depth.  It was hard to adjust and slipped over time.
  • A big chisel is needed. A 2.5 inch one would be ideal. Even bigger would work best in the wide notches.
  • The routing of the 45 degree chamfer cleaned up the world of sins, and uneven depth of cuts.
  • Getting the saw aligned and stable was critical.  In the end, even after the modification of the Krebs guide to make it as long as possible, it was too small to guide the saw.
  • Creating a layout jig will be helpful when doing multiple cuts in the future.

Monday, April 30, 2012

My Mr Puzzle Limited Edition Burr

Lost Day, 2001 Limited Edition, Mr Puzzle
I had seen sketches of a 8 burr bounding frame before, but never actually seen one constructed until Brian Young, aka Mr Puzzle of Australia, created one in 2001 as a special edition.  This was one of my first special editions from Brian, and I have been collecting them ever since.

The puzzle is nicknamed "Lost Day", based on the time it will take to solve it.  Many people joke it is more like a lost weekend.  To quote Brian's website: "David Bruce designed this puzzle in 1985 and although he designed it by hand he did later have a computer check it’s assembly to ensure it was unique.  ...  The goal of the design was to make sure each of the eight corners was a different burr and that all were notchable burrs with no key piece".   The special editions for this puzzle are long gone, and about the only way to acquire one would be to find it on ebay or and auction site, or as many craftsmen might want to do, simply make it yourself.
 
AutoCAD for Mac Model of the Lost Day
This became one of the first puzzles that really inspired my thinking about making a habitable space.  The fact that each burr in "Lost Day" is different makes it nearly impossible to do at the scale of a timber frame, because it would be very difficult to raise and slide the timber and frame as you manipulate the puzzle.  This is easy when the sticks are a few ounces, but not when a 6 x 6 by 16 feet at about 130 lbs each.  On the Burr Puzzle Cabin, I made the burrs the same and designed them to be able to be assembled in a logical sequence, but when constructed it looks exactly like the "Lost Day" with 8 burrs.  Well actually the Burr Puzzle Cabin has evolved to 16 burrs when I added the roof structure. As you will see, it has become a lot more complicated.

Friday, April 6, 2012

The Six-Piece Burr Puzzle


1928, Bruce Publishing Company
The root of the burr puzzle is the six-piece burr puzzle.  An interlocking puzzle of 6 rods, with 2 on each axis at 90 degrees to each other.  The puzzle is known to date back to the 18th century and was produced in both Asia and Europe.  Six-piece burrs are also documented in the Bestelmeier Toy catalog from 1803.  According to the IBM research the first US patent was issued in 1917 for a burr puzzle.  Edwin Wyatt published Puzzles in Wood in 1928 documenting the construction of multiple burrs, and this book is still in reprint today.  Although burrs now can be found with odd solutions, ropes, magnets and pegs to complicate them, the purist puzzler knows the best are the simplest, in high precision notched wood.  Bill Cutler is the modern father of the burr puzzle having written his paper in 1978 that showed that there were 25 possible notchable pieces that can be put together in 314 ways.  A notchable piece  can be cut on a table saw with no inside corners.  Once you expand the concept to non notchable pieces, which require a chisel to notch and inside corner, there are 369 pieces in total and the possible solutions escalates to 119,979 ways to make a solid burr.  in all these cases a solid burr is one where there are no empty internal spaces in the assembled puzzle.  Once you begin to analyze non-solid burrs, as Bill Cutler did in the 80s through the mid 90s, the combinations become astronomical numbering about 35 billion and requiring multiple moves to even separate the first piece.  The masters of today's Burr puzzles, still include Bill Cutler, joined by Stewart Coffin, Philippe Dubois, and Peter Marineau.  Many other have now come up with wonderful designs expanding from the simple six-piece burr  to ones that are 6 by 6 by 6 and some that are not even rectilinear.

IBM's Site at http://www.research.ibm.com

A few sites tell the story of the 6 piece Burr, but in my opinion, none is better than IBM site: http://www.research.ibm.com/BurrPuzzles.  I first discovered this site as a fantastic way to understand the history, the mathematical terminology and the huge variety of Burr puzzles, all made up from six rods.  I believe the site was an early experiment in cloud computing, which I find very purposeful and successful.  This predates the wilder experiments such as "Watson" which many of you might be familiar with from Jeopardy.  This site has not only the history, some of which I referenced above, but all the definitions and detailed descriptions of the mathematical nomenclature.  The site also has a burr calculator to help you design your own puzzles, or even solve the ones you have that you simply cannot figure out how to put back together.  It is the first stop for any novice burr puzzler, and the reference that everyone still uses, although many of the links are outdated because IBM does not maintain the site.a quick Google search will fill in the gaps.  and i will cover some of my other favorite sites in a future blog.